Close

Poetry submissions – stats for last 6 months, stocktake

poetry files

Just a quick update on my poetry submissions, in case you’re interested – I know people often like a comparison, and while those “I’m delighted to announce…” successes are all very nice to hear about, sometimes it’s good be reassured that you’re not the only one who’s not currently delighted about anything.  So, I’ve just done a 6 month audit and here’s what my submissions tracker tells me:

Magazines, waiting on:
4 poems currently out for 193 days
4 poems out for 168 days
5 poems out for 113 days
3 out for 8 days

There seems to be a long gap (no poems sent out between November and February) but that’s not entirely true, as some things were sent and returned in that time. Thanks so much to Antiphon and Ambit (among others) for your prompt responses!

Since last August I’ve had 24 poems declined by 6 magazines and 2 accepted.

Competitions: I’ve entered 11 poems in six competitions, the results of which are one 1st placed poem, one shortlisted and two sunk without trace, with the 3 remaining comps still to be judged.

On the whole I think I’ve sent out less material during this period than I’ve done in the past. I don’t have a fixed strategy, you know, such as sending a poem straight back out as soon as it’s returned. I also think I’m a bit more circumspect than I used to be.

When I first starting sending poems to magazines in early 2010, I think the first few acceptances (when they came) were like a drug – I was awash with the confidence that’s easy to have when you’re new to something. Ignorance is bliss, I suppose – and as with anything, the more you learn the more you realise the extent of that ignorance, and are humbled by it. So now I tend to sit on a poem that’s been declined, maybe go back to it a few weeks or months later, fiddle with it, wonder if it would fit another publication, sit on it a bit longer.

The other day I spent the evening filing – although I keep everything on the computer I do print poems off when I send them somewhere, or read them at an event. I’ve decided to archive a huge number of poems – the ones that never lived up to my own assessment of their merit – and I’m aiming to keep the “working on / not out at the moment” pile small. Instead of endless tweaking, I’m focusing more on writing new material. I’ve basically let go of a lot of stuff. It makes it easier to  look forward rather than back, and for me at least that’s important, as is a belief that the best work is yet to come. Do you agree? Any thoughts?

0 Comments on “Poetry submissions – stats for last 6 months, stocktake

  • Peter Raynard
    February 25, 2015 at 2:33 pm

    For someone who is at the start of submitting poems, this is really interesting and useful Robin; even the dispiriting parts about length of time it takes to hear back (if at all) and the rejections. I say to myself I am prepared for it, but I’m not sure. I’d take your point about leaving a poem alone when it has been turned down, but hasn’t it been left for some time anyway. Having said that, I very much agree with moving on from a poem – it is never a waste of time writing it, because the act of writing is meant to be enjoyable. At least some of the time.

    Reply
  • Robin Houghton
    February 25, 2015 at 2:42 pm

    Hi Peter, and thanks – yes, the act of writing is the enjoyable bit, and it helps if you also find submitting (mostly) enjoyable, despite the typically low success rate! I think of it as being like golf. You may only play one great shot in a game, and (certainly in my case) at least 100 rubbish ones, but the feeling when it goes well, when you’re in the zone, is priceless, plus you get a good walk, a scenic location and good company to boot.

    Reply
  • Heather Walker (@Heather91404743)
    February 25, 2015 at 4:35 pm

    I love reading how others work and file so I enjoyed this post very much. Like you I have some poems I wonder whether it is better to just abandon but others I believe in and keep sending them out in the hope that someone else will believe in it too. I do go back and re-visit poems and edit if they’ve been around a long time – often if I’ve not looked at them in a while I might spot something I don’t like anymore. I am writing new stuff now and then and have quite a few entered into competitions and to a magazine and feel all my best stuff is out so unless I edit some old poetry or write new ones I’m a bit stuck right now! While I have everything on my laptop I also keep files with hard copies of everything so I can refer to them anytime and work on old poems without having to fire up the laptop.

    Hope you get some responses to your submitted poems soon – waiting is awful!

    Reply
    • Robin Houghton
      February 27, 2015 at 9:54 am

      Hi Heather and thanks for the feedback! It’s interesting to read about your process, it sounds very similar to mine. We need to both get writing more! Good luck with your submissions 🙂

      Reply
  • Cathy Bryant
    February 26, 2015 at 12:00 pm

    Your blog is one of the most honest around, which is one reason that I love it. Thanks for this! I don’t send a poem straight back out either – for one thing, it needs to be proofread again in case I missed something (or the repetition of a word, the use of a cliché, or some other problem) the first time.
    I do a stocktake at the end of each calendar year. This was 2014’s: Summary: 234 submissions, 38 acceptances, wins or placings. A hit rate of 1 in 6.157. My best year was 2011 when my hit rate was 1 in 4, but that was before I concentrated on paying markets.
    I try not to get upset about it. The writing really is the thing.
    I have a huge love for Ambit and The Threepenny Review, who always reject me at the speed of light. Good luck with the poems that are being assessed by snails, and I hope that you get huge cheques for them soon.

    Reply
    • Robin Houghton
      February 27, 2015 at 9:59 am

      Wow Cathy that’s an impressive number of submissions and a great payback – thanks so much for sharing that! I feel like a grade-A slacker. Must write & send out more!! Although as you say, the writing’s the thing. I tell myself ‘the muse can’t be forced’ but that’s a bit silly really – professional poets of course can and do write to order (when commissioned, for example.) I think I just need to be more disciplined. Thanks for your good wishes.

      Reply
  • Claire Walker
    February 28, 2015 at 8:34 pm

    Hi Robin, I agree about the importance of letting go of certain poems. I’ve found it hard to do this sometimes, especially if it’s a poem I’ve been particularly attached to and it can be frustrating – upsetting even – if it is rejected by several different magazines! But I think I’m getting better at accepting that some poems just don’t work and it’s best to file them away. I totally agree with you about not looking back and believing the best is still ahead. I found it really interesting to see your submissions track, thanks for sharing it 🙂

    Reply
    • Robin Houghton
      March 3, 2015 at 8:39 am

      Thanks for commenting, Claire, and glad you enjoyed the post 🙂

      Reply
  • debrafox1
    March 7, 2015 at 6:15 pm

    Actually, I found this very encouraging- I am pleased I am not the only person to face disappointment. I had a script for a 10 minute play rejected in January, but was helped by a writing pal who said it is just part of the creative process!

    Reply
    • Robin Houghton
      March 9, 2015 at 9:49 am

      Thanks Debra! No, you’re definitely not the only one!

      Reply
  • A poetry Spring clean | poetgal
    May 11, 2015 at 11:41 am

    […] I am also doing a ruthless cull of outstanding submissions. Yes folks, I’ve taken a unilateral decision – and no doubt some people will find this controversial – to finally consider dead those submissions I’ve been waiting on since August and September last year. Inasmuch as I’m taking them out of the ‘pending’ folder and either resubmitting, editing or shelving them.  Here’s how it all ended (an update to a previous post on this topic): […]

    Reply
  • Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    %d bloggers like this: